Inside Out with Yuliya Popova: Ukrainian filmmakers missing the great stories

Print version
Sept. 23, 2011, 2:08 a.m. | About Kyiv — by Yuliya Popova
A two-act ballet performance lasts at least two hours. A documentary is usually half that length. To watch a documentary about ballet presented by French culture festival “Paris As It Is” on Sept. 19, I carved two hours and 40 minutes, or 1/10, out of my day, but it was certainly worth it.

Filmed in 2009, “La Danse: The Paris Opera Ballet” is a journey through famed Opera Garnier, its dancers, instructors, directors and even cleaners.

It has no voice-over; director Frederick Wiseman let the camera speak for itself while traversing through rehearsal studios, administrative offices and actual performances. Sometimes he would peep into a staff meeting when dancers discuss pensions and strikes; another time he would drop into the office to follow the gritty business of selling tours to Americans.

This story of modern livelihood of the opera house told in the present tense – without curtsies to its Napoleonic history – got me thinking about Ukrainian film industry and the stories we choose to tell. Sadly, most of the modern films and documentaries I can recall dwell on history, and usually the bitter side of it.

Minimalism and simplicity drives modern ballet. (

During a recent movie pitching session organized by the State Film Agency, young and old film directors brought their ideas along to win a partial subsidy from the government. A good number of the pitches were about war, Chornobyl, Stepan Bandera and other famous historic figures and events.

While I am not diminishing their importance in the world of cinema, I would have liked to see more films about present-day Ukraine. There are tons of ideas floating around.

How about immigration stories? There are at least three million Ukrainians living abroad. What initially was intended to be a one- or two-year sojourn for many of them to make money has become a permanent solution.
While I am not diminishing their importance in the world of cinema, I would have liked to see more films about present-day Ukraine. There are tons of ideas floating around.

Then, how about the story on Kyiv Mayor Leonid Chernovetsky? His “space” adventures, flirting with babushkas and current fall from grace, spiced up with a dirty divorce, could provide a good plot for a melodrama. Zooming in on his time in office would turn into a colorful base for a political thriller.

And what about a love affair from Lviv? This charming city has a swath of love stories to rival thousands of pictures filmed in and about Paris.

But no, from the long list of history-strewn stories presented at the pitching session, I weeded out a bloody thriller at Obolon, a senseless comedy about sex in space and one art-house picture about family dynamics in Lviv over Christmas (this one I actually thought was excellent). But it was not enough.

Films, of course, are a very subjective issue to discuss even with your friends, let alone with thousands of readers. And yet, how many films about modern Ukraine can you remember? The Orange Revolution inspired a couple, but the euphoria of filming a picture on contemporary issues seems to have died as quickly as the Orange leaders fell out.

There are, however, a couple of films made by foreign directors about modern Ukraine that really inspire.

“The English Surgeon,” the award-winning documentary by Australian director Geoffrey Smith, was released in 2008. It made a star out of London-based neurosurgeon Henry Marsh, who has been coming to Ukraine for more than 15 years to donate his skills and operate on patients that the Ukrainian medical system considers hopeless.

His Ukrainian co-star, Dr. Ihor Kurilets, in the documentary exposes Ukraine’s outdated medical system, poverty and ignorance in his daily work at a hospital in Kyiv.

The 2010 film by German director Jacob Preuss, “The Other Chelsea. The story from Donetsk,” shows Donetsk as a place where rich and poor share the same passion – football. Miners with their miniscule wages and a handful of oligarchs with millions of dollars – all converge on a stadium.
Some may argue that it’s hard to get inspired in Ukraine’s corrupt reality (and it may not be safe at times). And so young writers find it easier to sell the kind of stories Soviet-born film directors feel comfortable with.

Oh, and don’t forget that documentary “Klitschko” about Ukrainian brothers’ humble beginnings and astounding boxing success was also filmed by a German. It premiered in New York this spring, and we are still waiting to sample it in Kyiv.

Some may argue that it’s hard to get inspired in Ukraine’s corrupt reality (and it may not be safe at times). And so young writers find it easier to sell the kind of stories Soviet-born film directors feel comfortable with.

At least this seemed to be the case with the State Film Agency that approved financing for films about Ukrainian philosophers, church leaders and Chornobyl.

Predictably, everything new (unless the invention is in the Silicon Valley) is treated with a great deal of skepticism pretty much anywhere.

Even the young ballet dancers in “La Danse” are reticent to accept that ballet today is no longer just “The Nutcracker.” Opera artistic directors in the French documentary encourage staff to take modern dance classes and leave their tutus for a special occasion.

The audience wants those spiky new works by younger choreographers, in which ballet stars look almost like gymnasts – modestly dressed, sharp in their motion and realistic in their story-telling.

If the French can break from the past, so can Ukrainians.

Kyiv Post lifestyle editor Yuliya Popova can be reached at
The Kyiv Post is hosting comments to foster lively debate. Criticism is fine, but stick to the issues. Comments that include profanity or personal attacks will be removed from the site. If you think that a posted comment violates these standards, please flag it and alert us. We will take steps to block violators.
Anonymous Sept. 23, 2011, 11:53 p.m.    

An emerging Ukrainian film maker is Bohdana Smyrnova. She is a graduate of both the Karpenko-Kary and the NYU Film School to which she won a full fellowship. After NYU, she won a six month residency fellowship in Paris thanks to the Cannes Film Festival. Bohdana is planning to shoot her first feature length film in 2012. I believe it will be about a woman who has emigrated from Chernivtsi to New York. In any case, it will be shot in both of these cities.

Bohdan A Oryshkevich

{# <-- parent id goes here
Paul Worthington May 14, 2012, 12:48 a.m.    

Say Yulia, have you heard about the Ukrainian-Canadian Larysa Kondracki who made the great film &quot;WHISTLEBLOWER&quot; starring, among others the great Vanessa Redgrave?

The most heartbreaking Ukrainian written and directed, Ukrainian acted and themed. Featuring over 4 major Ukrainian actress parts in the Ukrainian language. A portrait of contemporary Ukraine as true as &quot;Dreamlife of Angels&quot; is to contemporary France.


[first lines]

Raya: [in Ukrainian] I have to get home. Mama's gonna kill me.

Luba: No. You are staying with me tonight. Roman wants us there at nine in the morning. Raya, we've been over this. It's just a few months working in a hotel.

Raya: Yes, but...

Luba: You want to work at a Copyshack like your mother? He said it was both of us or nothing!

Raya: ...No.

[walks away]


Larysa Kondracki


Larysa Kondracki,

It's opening scences are in the Ukraine. Much Ukrainian language and current stories through the film. One of the great, real, Ukrainian stories of our time. It shows that deep in the heart of the Ukrainian is indeed a moral conscience.

It follows on the acclaimed award winning short film Viko, by Kondracki, which is also about the depth of morality and contemporary Ukraine.

Let me know what you think of the film.

{# <-- parent id goes here


© 1995–2014 Public Media

Web links to Kyiv Post material are allowed provided that they contain a URL hyperlink to the material and a maximum 500-character extract of the story. Otherwise, all materials contained on this site are protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced without the prior written permission of Public Media at
All information of the Interfax-Ukraine news agency placed on this web site is designed for internal use only. Its reproduction or distribution in any form is prohibited without a written permission of Interfax-Ukraine.